ON DECK FOR FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20th

ON DECK FOR FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20th

KEY POINTS:

  • The ANT is getting squished and the whole AI trade is softening
  • Canadian retail sales moment stalls into Q4, but it’s early
  • UK consumers are alive and kicking ahead of the holiday season
  • Trump presser unlikely to reveal much
  • Canadian trade pragmatism—what it could mean, and the opposing forces

The ANT got squished took the whole AI trade down with it. That’s one possible interpretation of what transpired in the wake of the biggest IPO ever. Anthropic initially rallied well above the $83 issuance price yesterday morning before settling back toward a more modest gain by day’s end. It’s down sharply in today’s pre-market. At no point did broader equities share in any enthusiasm which is perhaps a stark signal on the durability of the tech trade; recall that when SpaceX debuted in June, it rallied for a few days and coincided with general risk-on sentiment including across tech. Not this time. As Jay notes, there is more interest in Grand Theft Auto than Anthropic (chart 1). 

Chart 1: Anthropic or GTA?

After the S&P and Nasdaq both fell by 2%+ yesterday, futures are tracking a further decline in the vicinity of 1–2% declines this morning. TSX futures are also down by just under 1%. European cash markets are similarly lower.

Sovereign bonds are picking up the safe haven flows. Yields are down across the board in the US, Canada, and all of Europe. Oil is a touch lower but Trump is deferring talk on what to do with Iran until next month; my guess is he doesn’t want to rile up the GOP during the lame duck session when he needs them for other things. Gold is down another $60/oz. The dollar isn’t really benefiting as most major currencies are up against it.

CANADIAN RETAIL SALES MOMENTUM MAY BE STALLING, BUT IT’S EARLY

Canadian retail sales were up by 3.9% q/q SAAR in Q4 but are tentatively tracking just shy of a -2% q/q SAAR contraction in Q4 (chart 2). A lot of Q4 data still lies ahead including the key holiday season.

Chart 2: Canadian Real Retail Sales Growth

On a monthly basis, volumes were up by only 0.1% m/m SA in September. Nominal sales were up 0.8% (0.7% initial guidance) and revised up in August to 1.4% m/m (from 1.2%). October’s preliminary flash nominal guidance was -1.5% m/m SA; while we don’t get any details, our tracking of prices suggests this was driven by lower volumes. CPI-gas, for instance, was up 1.9% m/m SA in October.

UK CONSUMERS ARE ALIVE AND KICKING

UK retail sales volumes ex-gasoline beat expectations. October was up 0.9% m/m SA (0.1% consensus) with only a partial assist from a downward revision that presented a lower than previously understood starting point (-0.9% m/m instead of -0.7%). There has been positive momentum since 2024, but at a fairly tepid pace (chart 3).

Chart 3: UK Core Retail Sales Volumes

TRUMP’S PRESSER UNLIKELY TO REVEAL MUCH

Trump holds a presser at 12pmET today to sum up his Asia trip. Various reports indicate no breakthroughs in talks with Putin and Xi Jinping. Generalities about seeking to undermine the UN through reforms and doing likewise against the International Criminal Court reflect disturbingly common ground between the three. By all accounts, there was only rhetoric absent substantive agreement on key issues like Ukraine, Iran, US-China trade, etc.

CANADIAN TRADE PRAGMATISM

Dominic LeBlanc—the Canadian government’s lead on the trade file—floated a trial balloon in yesterday’s interview that sought acceptance for some reduced level of US tariffs against Canada. The broad tone had a feeling of moving to stage 5 in Maslow’s stages of grief—acceptance. He seeks an interim deal that would achieve some relief on Section 232 and Section 338 tariffs—ideally wiping out the latter and reducing the former—before then perhaps moving onto a broader CUSMA renegotiation. He did not expand upon what Canada would offer in terms of its retaliatory tariffs, investments, purchases of US goods such as defence companies or anything like that. The clear signal was to take what you can get now and keep trying. No firm timeline was set as guidance indicated negotiations may stretch into the new year. It’s difficult to fully judge what is being sought since there would be a lot of important bilateral details beneath just the tariff rates. The purpose of the interview was clearly to pave the way for an acceptance tone in what lies ahead while making it clear that a deal is not imminently at hand.

Critics may say dig in, as Canadians won’t accept any American tariffs and you don’t want to codify acceptance of tariffs against the longstanding spirit of the trade deal since that could make it impossible to unwind in future. They may say you’ve got the US administration on the ropes after a long laundry list of failures resulted in being totally wiped out in the midterm elections and potentially on a path to lose the Presidency. They may also say hold firm, the cavalry is coming, and that notwithstanding the concentrated pain to a narrow portion of the Canadian economy, Canada should sit back and rely on the US courts, Congress and voters to reverse US protectionism. Tariffs are part of what is hurting America in terms of affordability and maintaining them could further work against the GOP into 2028. They may say that the current unelected US cabinet is in its dying days so fade the rhetoric.

Others would say get some relief and keep pushing that rock up the hill in order to reduce the pain where feasible and keep negotiating. All or nothing has no place in trade negotiations. That you can die of old age before the US legal system gets around to doing anything in a system whereby the law you get is determined by money and politics. Ignore the insults and lack of professionalism from Trump and outsiders like Navarro’s angry tirades and who carries no influence. This camp may also argue against relying on the Democrats who had a chance to throw some tangible love at Canada but instead shot down Keystone XL and maintained Trump 1.0 tariffs when Biden was in office. His VP and failed presidential candidate—Kamala Harris—had voted against USMCA and opposed the TPP and was perhaps at best a more polite protectionist than the current administration. They could note that the ‘progressive,’ left-wing members of the faction that seems to be steering the Democrats are no friends of trade and commerce in general. This camp may also argue that time is of the essence in sectors most affected by tariffs and that playing the waiting game may be too costly. This camp could also say that Canada can still exact some revenge in its choices on what to buy, from whom, and who to include in its investment plans, such that Canada has plenty of negotiating leverage. It may also argue that Canada may pivot toward greater Chinese involvement in the Canadian economy as a continued evolution away from the US in terms of the falling US share of Canadian exports and falling US share of FDI into Canada as the rest of the world marches in.

Yet another consideration would be that anything you agree to with the Trump administration may not be worth the paper it’s printed on anyway so don’t kid yourself that any agreement would stand or that you could achieve anything further. That questionable considerations drive outcomes in Washington. And anything agreed upon that serves American auto and steel firms won’t matter anyway given the reluctance by some to live up to their commitments.

A still further consideration is that some US tariff pressure on Canada may be necessary in a perverse way. Wiping them away could stall or reverse domestic progress in Canada toward changing its ways on many fronts including major projects, tearing down barriers to growth and revitalizing its armed forces. This country needs a boot in the tenders in order to exact change, or else nothing gets done. Witness the last time around when a collective sigh of relief after the USMCA deal resulted in lost momentum to change things. Canada is a messy combination of competing governments and special interest groups that repeatedly thwart change.

Key is also how provincial governments respond, namely Ontario where much of the affected steel and auto industries are located.

As for the potential impact of some tariff relief, have a look at chart 4. If wiping out the 338 tariffs can be achieved, then the effective tariff rate (ETR) would drop by a little over three percentage points. US tariffs on Canadian energy and potash obviously make no sense and penalize Americans perhaps the most of any tariffs so maybe they’re most likely to see a reversal but that’s unknown at this point. Key then becomes the 232 tariffs on metals and autos. The domestic blowback in the US against aluminum tariffs when Quebec is a dominant provider might do Canada’s work for it. With reductions on auto and steel tariffs, the overall ETR could be meaningfully dropped to within the low single digit percentage points. Some would say make the affected firms whole by writing a cheque.

Chart 4: Average Tariff Rate on US Imports From Canada

It’s a political calculus with concentrated significance to a handful of sectors but with modest macroeconomic consequences. Canada has performed just fine in the tariffs era. The C$ has adjusted, the rates spread to the US may narrow going forward but Canadian borrowing costs are likely to remain lower than in the US, and US growth can continue to create an income-driven pull effect on Canadian exports. 

Rates Table